@Edunn when you set up your die did you use the same piece of brass each time you screwed the die further into the press?
I have read that that each time you screw the die in you should use a different piece of brass. If the same piece is used it work hardens and springs back more which gives the illusion that you have a .002" shoulder bump. The next piece of brass will spring back less because it has only been sized once. When you measured the second piece it may well have bumped back .005".
Bookmarks