I still have a older 35W HID, and a Maxtoch. The HID is now relegated to the parts bin, as the Maxtoch matches it for throw. The latest model Maxtoch should be even better.
Rabbits don't seem to be stunned by the cool tint HID or the warm tint LED. Perhaps Rabbits that have never been hunted may stop and try and figure out what the bright light is.
Bookmarks